Distinguishing types of correlated errors in superconducting qubits

  1. Hannah P. Binney,
  2. H. Douglas Pinckney,
  3. Kate Azar,
  4. Patrick M. Harrington,
  5. Shantanu Jha,
  6. Mingyu Li,
  7. Jiatong Yang,
  8. Felipe Contipelli,
  9. Renée DePencier Piñero,
  10. Michael Gingras,
  11. Bethany M. Niedzielski,
  12. Hannah Stickler,
  13. Mollie E. Schwartz,
  14. Jeffrey A. Grover,
  15. Max Hays,
  16. Kyle Serniak,
  17. Joseph A. Formaggio,
  18. and William D. Oliver
Errors in superconducting qubits that are correlated in time and space can pose problems for quantum error correction codes. Radiation from cosmic and terrestrial sources can increase
the quasiparticle (QP) density in a superconducting qubit device, resulting in an increased rate of QPs tunneling across proximal Josephson junctions (JJs) and causing correlated errors. Mechanical vibrations, such as those induced by the pulse tube in a dry dilution refrigerator, are also a known source of correlated errors. We present a method for distinguishing these two types of errors by their temporal, spatial, and frequency domain features, enabling physically motivated error-mitigation strategies. We also present accelerometer data to study the correlation between dilution refrigerator vibrations and the errors. We measure arrays of transmon qubits where the difference in superconducting gap across the JJ is less than the qubit energy, as well as those where the gap is greater than the qubit energy, which has been shown to mitigate radiation-induced errors. We show that these latter devices are also protected against vibration-induced errors.

Characterization of Radiation-Induced Errors in Superconducting Qubits Protected with Various Gap-Engineering Strategies

  1. H. Douglas Pinckney,
  2. Thomas McJunkin,
  3. Alan W. Hunt,
  4. Patrick M. Harrington,
  5. Hannah P. Binney,
  6. Max Hays,
  7. Yenuel Jones-Alberty,
  8. Kate Azar,
  9. Felipe Contipelli,
  10. Renée DePencier Piñero,
  11. Jeffrey M. Gertler,
  12. Michael Gingras,
  13. Aranya Goswami,
  14. Cyrus F. Hirjibehedin,
  15. Mingyu Li,
  16. Mathis Moes,
  17. Bethany M. Niedzielski,
  18. Mallika T. Randeria,
  19. Ryan Sitler,
  20. Matthew K. Spear,
  21. Hannah Stickler,
  22. Jiatong Yang,
  23. Wouter Van De Pontseele,
  24. Mollie E. Schwartz,
  25. Jeffrey A. Grover,
  26. Kevin Schultz,
  27. Kyle Serniak,
  28. Joseph A. Formaggio,
  29. and William D. Oliver
Impacts from high-energy particles cause correlated errors in superconducting qubits by increasing the quasiparticle density in the vicinity of the Josephson junctions (JJs). Such errors
are particularly harmful as they cannot be easily remedied via conventional error correcting codes. Recent experiments reduced correlated errors by making the difference in superconducting gap energy across the JJ larger than the qubit energy. In this work, we assess gap engineering near the JJ (δΔJJ) and the capacitor/ground-plane (δΔM1) by exposing arrays of transmon qubits to two sources of radiation. For α-particles from an 241Am source, we observe T1 errors correlated in space and time, supporting a hypothesis that hadronic cosmic rays are a major contributor to the 10−10 error floor observed in Ref. 1. For electrons from a pulsed linear accelerator, we observe temporally correlated T1 and T2 errors, this measurement is insensitive to spatial correlations. We observe that the severity of correlated T1 errors is reduced for qubit arrays with a greater degree of gap engineering at the JJ. For both T1 and T2 errors, the recovery time is hastened by an increased δΔM1, which we attribute to the trapping of quasiparticles into the capacitor/ground-plane. We construct a model of quasiparticle dynamics that qualitatively agrees with our observations. This work reinforces the multifaceted influence of radiation on superconducting qubits and provides strategies for improving radiation resilience.

ZZ-Free Two-Transmon CZ Gate Mediated by a Fluxonium Coupler

  1. Junyoung An,
  2. Helin Zhang,
  3. Qi Ding,
  4. Leon Ding,
  5. Youngkyu Sung,
  6. Roni Winik,
  7. Junghyun Kim,
  8. Ilan T. Rosen,
  9. Kate Azar,
  10. Renee DePencier Piñero,
  11. Jeffrey M. Gertler,
  12. Michael Gingras,
  13. Bethany M. Niedzielski,
  14. Hannah Stickler,
  15. Mollie E. Schwartz,
  16. Joel I.J. Wang,
  17. Terry P. Orlando,
  18. Simon Gustavsson,
  19. Max Hays,
  20. Jeffrey A. Grover,
  21. Kyle Serniak,
  22. and William D. Oliver
Eliminating residual ZZ interactions in a two-qubit system is essential for reducing coherent errors during quantum operations. In a superconducting circuit platform, coupling two transmon
qubits via a transmon coupler has been shown to effectively suppress residual ZZ interactions. However, in such systems, perfect cancellation usually requires the qubit-qubit detuning to be smaller than the individual qubit anharmonicities, which exacerbates frequency crowding and microwave crosstalk. To address this limitation, we introduce TFT (Transmon-Fluxonium-Transmon) architecture, wherein two transmon qubits are coupled via a fluxonium qubit. The coupling mediated by the fluxonium eliminates residual ZZ interactions even for transmons detuned larger than their anharmonicities. We experimentally identified zero-ZZ interaction points at qubit-qubit detunings of 409 MHz and 616 MHz from two distinct TFT devices. We then implemented an adiabatic, coupler-flux-biased controlled-Z gate on both devices, achieving CZ gate fidelities of 99.64(6)% and 99.68(8)%.

Probing Sensitivity near a Quantum Exceptional Point using Waveguide Quantum Electrodynamics

  1. Aziza Almanakly,
  2. Reouven Assouly,
  3. Harry Hanlim Kang,
  4. Michael Gingras,
  5. Bethany M. Niedzielski,
  6. Hannah Stickler,
  7. Mollie E. Schwartz,
  8. Kyle Serniak,
  9. Max Hays,
  10. Jeffrey A. Grover,
  11. and William D. Oliver
Non-Hermitian Hamiltonians with complex eigenenergies are useful tools for describing the dynamics of open quantum systems. In particular, parity and time (PT) symmetric Hamiltonians
have generated interest due to the emergence of exceptional-point degeneracies, where both eigenenergies and eigenvectors coalesce as the energy spectrum transitions from real- to complex-valued. Because of the abrupt spectral response near exceptional points, such systems have been proposed as candidates for precision quantum sensing. In this work, we emulate a passive \PT~dimer using a two-mode, non-Hermitian system of superconducting qubits comprising one high-coherence qubit coupled to an intentionally lossy qubit via a tunable coupler. The loss is introduced by strongly coupling the qubit to a continuum of photonic modes in an open waveguide environment. Using both pulsed and continuous-wave measurements, we characterize the system dynamics near the exceptional point. We observe a behavior broadly consistent with an ideal passive \PT~dimer with some corrections due to the tunable coupler element. We extract the complex eigenenergies associated with the two modes and calculate the sensitivity as a function of the coupling strength. Confirming theoretical predictions, we observe no sensitivity enhancement near the quantum exceptional point. This study elucidates the limitations of exceptional-point systems as candidates for quantum-enhanced sensing.

Temperature and Magnetic-Field Dependence of Energy Relaxation in a Fluxonium Qubit

  1. Lamia Ateshian,
  2. Max Hays,
  3. David A. Rower,
  4. Helin Zhang,
  5. Kate Azar,
  6. Réouven Assouly,
  7. Leon Ding,
  8. Michael Gingras,
  9. Hannah Stickler,
  10. Bethany M. Niedzielski,
  11. Mollie E. Schwartz,
  12. Terry P. Orlando,
  13. Joel I.J. Wang,
  14. Simon Gustavsson,
  15. Jeffrey A. Grover,
  16. Kyle Serniak,
  17. and William D. Oliver
Noise from material defects at device interfaces is known to limit the coherence of superconducting circuits, yet our understanding of the defect origins and noise mechanisms remains
incomplete. Here we investigate the temperature and in-plane magnetic-field dependence of energy relaxation in a low-frequency fluxonium qubit, where the sensitivity to flux noise and charge noise arising from dielectric loss can be tuned by applied flux. We observe an approximately linear scaling of flux noise with temperature T and a power-law dependence of dielectric loss T3 up to 100 mK. Additionally, we find that the dielectric-loss-limited T1 decreases with weak in-plane magnetic fields, suggesting a potential magnetic-field response of the underlying charge-coupled defects. We implement a multi-level decoherence model in our analysis, motivated by the widely tunable matrix elements and transition energies approaching the thermal energy scale in our system. These findings offer insight for fluxonium coherence modeling and should inform microscopic theories of intrinsic noise in superconducting circuits.

Deterministic remote entanglement using a chiral quantum interconnect

  1. Aziza Almanakly,
  2. Beatriz Yankelevich,
  3. Max Hays,
  4. Bharath Kannan,
  5. Reouven Assouly,
  6. Alex Greene,
  7. Michael Gingras,
  8. Bethany M. Niedzielski,
  9. Hannah Stickler,
  10. Mollie E. Schwartz,
  11. Kyle Serniak,
  12. Joel I.J. Wang,
  13. Terry P. Orlando,
  14. Simon Gustavsson,
  15. Jeffrey A. Grover,
  16. and William D. Oliver
Quantum interconnects facilitate entanglement distribution between non-local computational nodes. For superconducting processors, microwave photons are a natural means to mediate this
distribution. However, many existing architectures limit node connectivity and directionality. In this work, we construct a chiral quantum interconnect between two nominally identical modules in separate microwave packages. We leverage quantum interference to emit and absorb microwave photons on demand and in a chosen direction between these modules. We optimize the protocol using model-free reinforcement learning to maximize absorption efficiency. By halting the emission process halfway through its duration, we generate remote entanglement between modules in the form of a four-qubit W state with 62.4 +/- 1.6% (leftward photon propagation) and 62.1 +/- 1.2% (rightward) fidelity, limited mainly by propagation loss. This quantum network architecture enables all-to-all connectivity between non-local processors for modular and extensible quantum computation.

Interferometric Purcell suppression of spontaneous emission in a superconducting qubit

  1. Alec Yen,
  2. Yufeng Ye,
  3. Kaidong Peng,
  4. Jennifer Wang,
  5. Gregory Cunningham,
  6. Michael Gingras,
  7. Bethany M. Niedzielski,
  8. Hannah Stickler,
  9. Kyle Serniak,
  10. Mollie E. Schwartz,
  11. and Kevin P. O'Brien
In superconducting qubits, suppression of spontaneous emission is essential to achieve fast dispersive measurement and reset without sacrificing qubit lifetime. We show that resonator-mediated
decay of the qubit mode to the feedline can be suppressed using destructive interference, where the readout resonator is coupled to the feedline at two points. This „interferometric Purcell filter“ does not require dedicated filter components or impedance mismatch in the feedline, making it suitable for applications such as all-pass readout. We design and fabricate a device with the proposed scheme and demonstrate suppression of resonator-mediated decay that exceeds 2 orders of magnitude over a bandwidth of 400 MHz.

Dephasing in Fluxonium Qubits from Coherent Quantum Phase Slips

  1. Mallika T. Randeria,
  2. Thomas M. Hazard,
  3. Agustin Di Paolo,
  4. Kate Azar,
  5. Max Hays,
  6. Leon Ding,
  7. Junyoung An,
  8. Michael Gingras,
  9. Bethany M. Niedzielski,
  10. Hannah Stickler,
  11. Jeffrey A. Grover,
  12. Jonilyn L. Yoder,
  13. Mollie E. Schwartz,
  14. William D. Oliver,
  15. and Kyle Serniak
Phase slips occur across all Josephson junctions (JJs) at a rate that increases with the impedance of the junction. In superconducting qubits composed of JJ-array superinductors —
such as fluxonium — phase slips in the array can lead to decoherence. In particular, phase-slip processes at the individual array junctions can coherently interfere, each with an Aharonov–Casher phase that depends on the offset charges of the array islands. These coherent quantum phase slips (CQPS) perturbatively modify the qubit frequency, and therefore charge noise on the array islands will lead to dephasing. By varying the impedance of the array junctions, we design a set of fluxonium qubits in which the expected phase-slip rate within the JJ-array changes by several orders of magnitude. We characterize the coherence times of these qubits and demonstrate that the scaling of CQPS-induced dephasing rates agrees with our theoretical model. Furthermore, we perform noise spectroscopy of two qubits in regimes dominated by either CQPS or flux noise. We find the noise power spectrum associated with CQPS dephasing appears to be featureless at low frequencies and not 1/f. Numerical simulations indicate this behavior is consistent with charge noise generated by charge-parity fluctuations within the array. Our findings broadly inform JJ-array-design tradeoffs, relevant for the numerous superconducting qubit designs employing JJ-array superinductors.

All-Pass Readout for Robust and Scalable Quantum Measurement

  1. Alec Yen,
  2. Yufeng Ye,
  3. Kaidong Peng,
  4. Jennifer Wang,
  5. Gregory Cunningham,
  6. Michael Gingras,
  7. Bethany M. Niedzielski,
  8. Hannah Stickler,
  9. Kyle Serniak,
  10. Mollie E. Schwartz,
  11. and Kevin P. O'Brien
Robust and scalable multiplexed qubit readout will be essential to the realization of a fault-tolerant quantum computer. To this end, we propose and demonstrate transmission-based dispersive
readout of a superconducting qubit using an all-pass resonator that preferentially emits readout photons in one direction. This is in contrast to typical readout schemes, which intentionally mismatch the feedline at one end so that the readout signal preferentially decays toward the output. We show that this intentional mismatch creates scaling challenges, including larger spread of effective resonator linewidths due to non-ideal impedance environments and added infrastructure for impedance matching. Our proposed „all-pass readout“ architecture avoids the need for intentional mismatch and aims to enable reliable, modular design of multiplexed qubit readout, thus improving the scaling prospects of quantum computers. We design and fabricate an all-pass readout resonator that demonstrates insertion loss below 1.17 dB at the readout frequency and a maximum insertion loss of 1.53 dB across its full bandwidth for the lowest three states of a transmon qubit. We demonstrate qubit readout with an average single-shot fidelity of 98.1% in 600 ns; to assess the effect of larger dispersive shift, we implement a shelving protocol and achieve a fidelity of 99.0% in 300 ns.

Directional emission of a readout resonator for qubit measurement

  1. Alec Yen,
  2. Yufeng Ye,
  3. Kaidong Peng,
  4. Jennifer Wang,
  5. Gregory Cunningham,
  6. Michael Gingras,
  7. Bethany M. Niedzielski,
  8. Hannah Stickler,
  9. Kyle Serniak,
  10. Mollie E. Schwartz,
  11. and Kevin P. O'Brien
We propose and demonstrate transmission-based dispersive readout of a superconducting qubit using an all-pass resonator, which preferentially emits readout photons toward the output.
This is in contrast to typical readout schemes, which intentionally mismatch the feedline at one end so that the readout signal preferentially decays toward the output. We show that this intentional mismatch creates scaling challenges, including larger spread of effective resonator linewidths due to non-ideal impedance environments and added infrastructure for impedance matching. A future architecture using multiplexed all-pass readout resonators would avoid the need for intentional mismatch and potentially improve the scaling prospects of quantum computers. As a proof-of-concept demonstration of „all-pass readout,“ we design and fabricate an all-pass readout resonator that demonstrates insertion loss below 1.17 dB at the readout frequency and a maximum insertion loss of 1.53 dB across its full bandwidth for the lowest three states of a transmon qubit. We demonstrate qubit readout with an average single-shot fidelity of 98.1% in 600 ns; to assess the effect of larger dispersive shift, we implement a shelving protocol and achieve a fidelity of 99.0% in 300 ns.