Wafer-scale uniformity of Dolan-bridge and bridgeless Manhattan-style Josephson junctions for superconducting quantum processors

  1. N. Muthusubramanian,
  2. P. Duivestein,
  3. C. Zachariadis,
  4. M. Finkel,
  5. S. L. M. van der Meer,
  6. H. M. Veen,
  7. M. W. Beekman,
  8. T. Stavenga,
  9. A. Bruno,
  10. and L. DiCarlo
We investigate die-level and wafer-scale uniformity of Dolan-bridge and bridgeless Manhattan Josephson junctions, using multiple substrates with and without through-silicon vias (TSVs).
Dolan junctions fabricated on planar substrates have the highest yield and lowest room-temperature conductance spread, equivalent to ~100 MHz in transmon frequency. In TSV-integrated substrates, Dolan junctions suffer most in both yield and disorder, making Manhattan junctions preferable. Manhattan junctions show pronounced conductance decrease from wafer centre to edge, which we qualitatively capture using a geometric model of spatially-dependent resist shadowing during junction electrode evaporation. Analysis of actual junction overlap areas using scanning electron micrographs supports the model, and further points to a remnant spatial dependence possibly due to contact resistance.

Realization of a quantum neural network using repeat-until-success circuits in a superconducting quantum processor

  1. M. S. Moreira,
  2. G. G. Guerreschi,
  3. W. Vlothuizen,
  4. J. F. Marques,
  5. J. van Straten,
  6. S. P. Premaratne,
  7. X. Zou,
  8. H. Ali,
  9. N. Muthusubramanian,
  10. C. Zachariadis,
  11. J. van Someren,
  12. M. Beekman,
  13. N. Haider,
  14. A. Bruno,
  15. C. G. Almudever,
  16. A. Y. Matsuura,
  17. and L. DiCarlo
Artificial neural networks are becoming an integral part of digital solutions to complex problems. However, employing neural networks on quantum processors faces challenges related
to the implementation of non-linear functions using quantum circuits. In this paper, we use repeat-until-success circuits enabled by real-time control-flow feedback to realize quantum neurons with non-linear activation functions. These neurons constitute elementary building blocks that can be arranged in a variety of layouts to carry out deep learning tasks quantum coherently. As an example, we construct a minimal feedforward quantum neural network capable of learning all 2-to-1-bit Boolean functions by optimization of network activation parameters within the supervised-learning paradigm. This model is shown to perform non-linear classification and effectively learns from multiple copies of a single training state consisting of the maximal superposition of all inputs.

Logical-qubit operations in an error-detecting surface code

  1. J. F. Marques,
  2. B. M. Varbanov,
  3. M. S. Moreira,
  4. H. Ali,
  5. N. Muthusubramanian,
  6. C. Zachariadis,
  7. F. Battistel,
  8. M. Beekman,
  9. N. Haider,
  10. W. Vlothuizen,
  11. A. Bruno,
  12. B. M. Terhal,
  13. and L. DiCarlo
We realize a suite of logical operations on a distance-two logical qubit stabilized using repeated error detection cycles. Logical operations include initialization into arbitrary states,
measurement in the cardinal bases of the Bloch sphere, and a universal set of single-qubit gates. For each type of operation, we observe higher performance for fault-tolerant variants over non-fault-tolerant variants, and quantify the difference through detailed characterization. In particular, we demonstrate process tomography of logical gates, using the notion of a logical Pauli transfer matrix. This integration of high-fidelity logical operations with a scalable scheme for repeated stabilization is a milestone on the road to quantum error correction with higher-distance superconducting surface codes.

Variational preparation of finite-temperature states on a quantum computer

  1. R. Sagastizabal,
  2. S. P. Premaratne,
  3. B. A. Klaver,
  4. M. A. Rol,
  5. V. Negîrneac,
  6. M. Moreira,
  7. X. Zou,
  8. S. Johri,
  9. N. Muthusubramanian,
  10. M. Beekman,
  11. C. Zachariadis,
  12. V.P. Ostroukh,
  13. N. Haider,
  14. A. Bruno,
  15. A. Y. Matsuura,
  16. and L. DiCarlo
The preparation of thermal equilibrium states is important for the simulation of condensed-matter and cosmology systems using a quantum computer. We present a method to prepare such
mixed states with unitary operators, and demonstrate this technique experimentally using a gate-based quantum processor. Our method targets the generation of thermofield double states using a hybrid quantum-classical variational approach motivated by quantum-approximate optimization algorithms, without prior calculation of optimal variational parameters by numerical simulation. The fidelity of generated states to the thermal-equilibrium state smoothly varies from 99 to 75% between infinite and near-zero simulated temperature, in quantitative agreement with numerical simulations of the noisy quantum processor with error parameters drawn from experiment.

High-fidelity controlled-Z gate with maximal intermediate leakage operating at the speed limit in a superconducting quantum processor

  1. V. Negîrneac,
  2. H. Ali,
  3. N. Muthusubramanian,
  4. F. Battistel,
  5. R. Sagastizabal,
  6. M. S. Moreira,
  7. J. F. Marques,
  8. W. Vlothuizen,
  9. M. Beekman,
  10. N. Haider,
  11. A. Bruno,
  12. and L. DiCarlo
We introduce the sudden variant (SNZ) of the Net Zero scheme realizing controlled-Z (CZ) gates by baseband flux control of transmon frequency. SNZ CZ gates operate at the speed limit
of transverse coupling between computational and non-computational states by maximizing intermediate leakage. The key advantage of SNZ is tuneup simplicity, owing to the regular structure of conditional phase and leakage as a function of two control parameters. We realize SNZ CZ gates in a multi-transmon processor, achieving 99.93±0.24% fidelity and 0.10±0.02% leakage. SNZ is compatible with scalable schemes for quantum error correction and adaptable to generalized conditional-phase gates useful in intermediate-scale applications.

Protecting quantum entanglement from qubit errors and leakage via repetitive parity measurements

  1. C. C. Bultink,
  2. T. E. O'Brien,
  3. R. Vollmer,
  4. N. Muthusubramanian,
  5. M. W. Beekman,
  6. M. A. Rol,
  7. X. Fu,
  8. B. Tarasinski,
  9. V. Ostroukh,
  10. B. Varbanov,
  11. A. Bruno,
  12. and L. DiCarlo
Protecting quantum information from errors is essential for large-scale quantum computation. Quantum error correction (QEC) encodes information in entangled states of many qubits, and
performs parity measurements to identify errors without destroying the encoded information. However, traditional QEC cannot handle leakage from the qubit computational space. Leakage affects leading experimental platforms, based on trapped ions and superconducting circuits, which use effective qubits within many-level physical systems. We investigate how two-transmon entangled states evolve under repeated parity measurements, and demonstrate the use of hidden Markov models to detect leakage using only the record of parity measurement outcomes required for QEC. We show the stabilization of Bell states over up to 26 parity measurements by mitigating leakage using postselection, and correcting qubit errors using Pauli-frame transformations. Our leakage identification method is computationally efficient and thus compatible with real-time leakage tracking and correction in larger quantum processors.

Error Mitigation by Symmetry Verification on a Variational Quantum Eigensolver

  1. R. Sagastizabal,
  2. X. Bonet-Monroig,
  3. M. Singh,
  4. M. A. Rol,
  5. C. C. Bultink,
  6. X. Fu,
  7. C.H. Price,
  8. V.P. Ostroukh,
  9. N. Muthusubramanian,
  10. A. Bruno,
  11. M. Beekman,
  12. N. Haider,
  13. T. E. O'Brien,
  14. and L. DiCarlo
Variational quantum eigensolvers offer a small-scale testbed to demonstrate the performance of error mitigation techniques with low experimental overhead. We present successful error
mitigation by applying the recently proposed symmetry verification technique to the experimental estimation of the ground-state energy and ground state of the hydrogen molecule. A finely adjustable exchange interaction between two qubits in a circuit QED processor efficiently prepares variational ansatz states in the single-excitation subspace respecting the parity symmetry of the qubit-mapped Hamiltonian. Symmetry verification improves the energy and state estimates by mitigating the effects of qubit relaxation and residual qubit excitation, which violate the symmetry. A full-density-matrix simulation matching the experiment dissects the contribution of these mechanisms from other calibrated error sources. Enforcing positivity of the measured density matrix via scalable convex optimization correlates the energy and state estimate improvements when using symmetry verification, with interesting implications for determining system properties beyond the ground-state energy.

Tuneable hopping and nonlinear cross-Kerr interactions in a high-coherence superconducting circuit

  1. M. Kounalakis,
  2. C. Dickel,
  3. A. Bruno,
  4. N. K. Langford,
  5. and G. A. Steele
Analog quantum simulations offer rich opportunities for exploring complex quantum systems and phenomena through the use of specially engineered, well-controlled quantum systems. A critical
element, increasing the scope and flexibility of such experimental platforms, is the ability to access and tune in situ different interaction regimes. Here, we present a superconducting circuit building block of two highly coherent transmons featuring in situ tuneable photon hopping and nonlinear cross-Kerr couplings. The interactions are mediated via a nonlinear coupler, consisting of a large capacitor in parallel with a tuneable superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID). We demonstrate the working principle by experimentally characterising the system in the single- and two-excitation manifolds, and derive a full theoretical model that accurately describes our measurements. Both qubits have high coherence properties, with typical relaxation times in the range of 15 to 40 microseconds at all bias points of the coupler. Our device could be used as a scalable building block in analog quantum simulators of extended Bose-Hubbard and Heisenberg XXZ models, and may also have applications in quantum computing such as realising fast two-qubit gates and perfect state transfer protocols.

Chip-to-chip entanglement of transmon qubits using engineered measurement fields

  1. C. Dickel,
  2. J. J. Wesdorp,
  3. N. K. Langford,
  4. S. Peiter,
  5. R. Sagastizabal,
  6. A. Bruno,
  7. B. Criger,
  8. F. Motzoi,
  9. and L. DiCarlo
While the on-chip processing power in circuit QED devices is growing rapidly, an open challenge is to establish high-fidelity quantum links between qubits on different chips. Here,
we show entanglement between transmon qubits on different cQED chips with 49% concurrence and 73% Bell-state fidelity. We engineer a half-parity measurement by successively reflecting a coherent microwave field off two nearly-identical transmon-resonator systems. By ensuring the measured output field does not distinguish |01⟩ from |10⟩, unentangled superposition states are probabilistically projected onto entangled states in the odd-parity subspace. We use in-situ tunability and an additional weakly coupled driving field on the second resonator to overcome imperfect matching due to fabrication variations. To demonstrate the flexibility of this approach, we also produce an even-parity entangled state of similar quality, by engineering the matching of outputs for the |00⟩ and |11⟩ states. The protocol is characterized over a range of measurement strengths using quantum state tomography showing good agreement with a comprehensive theoretical model.

Evolution of Nanowire Transmons and Their Quantum Coherence in Magnetic Field

  1. F. Luthi,
  2. T. Stavenga,
  3. O. W. Enzing,
  4. A. Bruno,
  5. C. Dickel,
  6. N. K. Langford,
  7. M. A. Rol,
  8. T. S. Jespersen,
  9. J. Nygard,
  10. P. Krogstrup,
  11. and L. DiCarlo
We present an experimental study of nanowire transmons at zero and applied in-plane magnetic field. With Josephson non-linearities provided by the nanowires, our qubits operate at higher
magnetic fields than standard transmons. Nanowire transmons exhibit coherence up to 70 mT, where the induced superconducting gap in the nanowire closes. We demonstrate that on-chip charge noise coupling to the Josephson energy plays a dominant role in the qubit dephasing. This takes the form of strongly-coupled two-level systems switching on 100 ms timescales and a more weakly coupled background producing 1/f noise. Several observations, including the field dependence of qubit energy relaxation and dephasing, are not fully understood, inviting further experimental investigation and theory. Using nanowires with a thinner superconducting shell will enable operation of these circuits up to 0.5 T, a regime relevant for topological quantum computation.