Distinguishing types of correlated errors in superconducting qubits

  1. Hannah P. Binney,
  2. H. Douglas Pinckney,
  3. Kate Azar,
  4. Patrick M. Harrington,
  5. Shantanu Jha,
  6. Mingyu Li,
  7. Jiatong Yang,
  8. Felipe Contipelli,
  9. Renée DePencier Piñero,
  10. Michael Gingras,
  11. Bethany M. Niedzielski,
  12. Hannah Stickler,
  13. Mollie E. Schwartz,
  14. Jeffrey A. Grover,
  15. Max Hays,
  16. Kyle Serniak,
  17. Joseph A. Formaggio,
  18. and William D. Oliver
Errors in superconducting qubits that are correlated in time and space can pose problems for quantum error correction codes. Radiation from cosmic and terrestrial sources can increase
the quasiparticle (QP) density in a superconducting qubit device, resulting in an increased rate of QPs tunneling across proximal Josephson junctions (JJs) and causing correlated errors. Mechanical vibrations, such as those induced by the pulse tube in a dry dilution refrigerator, are also a known source of correlated errors. We present a method for distinguishing these two types of errors by their temporal, spatial, and frequency domain features, enabling physically motivated error-mitigation strategies. We also present accelerometer data to study the correlation between dilution refrigerator vibrations and the errors. We measure arrays of transmon qubits where the difference in superconducting gap across the JJ is less than the qubit energy, as well as those where the gap is greater than the qubit energy, which has been shown to mitigate radiation-induced errors. We show that these latter devices are also protected against vibration-induced errors.

Characterization of Radiation-Induced Errors in Superconducting Qubits Protected with Various Gap-Engineering Strategies

  1. H. Douglas Pinckney,
  2. Thomas McJunkin,
  3. Alan W. Hunt,
  4. Patrick M. Harrington,
  5. Hannah P. Binney,
  6. Max Hays,
  7. Yenuel Jones-Alberty,
  8. Kate Azar,
  9. Felipe Contipelli,
  10. Renée DePencier Piñero,
  11. Jeffrey M. Gertler,
  12. Michael Gingras,
  13. Aranya Goswami,
  14. Cyrus F. Hirjibehedin,
  15. Mingyu Li,
  16. Mathis Moes,
  17. Bethany M. Niedzielski,
  18. Mallika T. Randeria,
  19. Ryan Sitler,
  20. Matthew K. Spear,
  21. Hannah Stickler,
  22. Jiatong Yang,
  23. Wouter Van De Pontseele,
  24. Mollie E. Schwartz,
  25. Jeffrey A. Grover,
  26. Kevin Schultz,
  27. Kyle Serniak,
  28. Joseph A. Formaggio,
  29. and William D. Oliver
Impacts from high-energy particles cause correlated errors in superconducting qubits by increasing the quasiparticle density in the vicinity of the Josephson junctions (JJs). Such errors
are particularly harmful as they cannot be easily remedied via conventional error correcting codes. Recent experiments reduced correlated errors by making the difference in superconducting gap energy across the JJ larger than the qubit energy. In this work, we assess gap engineering near the JJ (δΔJJ) and the capacitor/ground-plane (δΔM1) by exposing arrays of transmon qubits to two sources of radiation. For α-particles from an 241Am source, we observe T1 errors correlated in space and time, supporting a hypothesis that hadronic cosmic rays are a major contributor to the 10−10 error floor observed in Ref. 1. For electrons from a pulsed linear accelerator, we observe temporally correlated T1 and T2 errors, this measurement is insensitive to spatial correlations. We observe that the severity of correlated T1 errors is reduced for qubit arrays with a greater degree of gap engineering at the JJ. For both T1 and T2 errors, the recovery time is hastened by an increased δΔM1, which we attribute to the trapping of quasiparticles into the capacitor/ground-plane. We construct a model of quasiparticle dynamics that qualitatively agrees with our observations. This work reinforces the multifaceted influence of radiation on superconducting qubits and provides strategies for improving radiation resilience.

Lattice field theory for superconducting circuits

  1. Joshua Lin,
  2. Max Hays,
  3. Stephen Sorokanich III,
  4. Julian Bender,
  5. Phiala E. Shanahan,
  6. and Neill C. Warrington
Large superconducting quantum circuits have a number of important applications in quantum computing. Accurately predicting the performance of these devices from first principles is
challenging, as it requires solving the many-body Schrödinger equation. This work introduces a new, general ab-initio method for analyzing large quantum circuits based on lattice field theory, a tool commonly applied in nuclear and particle physics. This method is competitive with state-of-the-art techniques such as tensor networks, but avoids introducing systematic errors due to truncation of the infinite-dimensional Hilbert space associated with superconducting phases. The approach is applied to fluxonium, a specific many-component superconducting qubit with favorable qualities for quantum computation. A systematic study of the influence of impedance on fluxonium is conducted that parallels previous experimental studies, and ground capacitance effects are explored. The qubit frequency and charge noise dephasing rate are extracted from statistical analyses of charge noise, where thousands of instantiations of charge disorder in the Josephson junction array of a fixed fluxonium qubit are explicitly averaged over at the microscopic level. This is difficult to achieve with any other existing method.

ZZ-Free Two-Transmon CZ Gate Mediated by a Fluxonium Coupler

  1. Junyoung An,
  2. Helin Zhang,
  3. Qi Ding,
  4. Leon Ding,
  5. Youngkyu Sung,
  6. Roni Winik,
  7. Junghyun Kim,
  8. Ilan T. Rosen,
  9. Kate Azar,
  10. Renee DePencier Piñero,
  11. Jeffrey M. Gertler,
  12. Michael Gingras,
  13. Bethany M. Niedzielski,
  14. Hannah Stickler,
  15. Mollie E. Schwartz,
  16. Joel I.J. Wang,
  17. Terry P. Orlando,
  18. Simon Gustavsson,
  19. Max Hays,
  20. Jeffrey A. Grover,
  21. Kyle Serniak,
  22. and William D. Oliver
Eliminating residual ZZ interactions in a two-qubit system is essential for reducing coherent errors during quantum operations. In a superconducting circuit platform, coupling two transmon
qubits via a transmon coupler has been shown to effectively suppress residual ZZ interactions. However, in such systems, perfect cancellation usually requires the qubit-qubit detuning to be smaller than the individual qubit anharmonicities, which exacerbates frequency crowding and microwave crosstalk. To address this limitation, we introduce TFT (Transmon-Fluxonium-Transmon) architecture, wherein two transmon qubits are coupled via a fluxonium qubit. The coupling mediated by the fluxonium eliminates residual ZZ interactions even for transmons detuned larger than their anharmonicities. We experimentally identified zero-ZZ interaction points at qubit-qubit detunings of 409 MHz and 616 MHz from two distinct TFT devices. We then implemented an adiabatic, coupler-flux-biased controlled-Z gate on both devices, achieving CZ gate fidelities of 99.64(6)% and 99.68(8)%.

Probing Sensitivity near a Quantum Exceptional Point using Waveguide Quantum Electrodynamics

  1. Aziza Almanakly,
  2. Reouven Assouly,
  3. Harry Hanlim Kang,
  4. Michael Gingras,
  5. Bethany M. Niedzielski,
  6. Hannah Stickler,
  7. Mollie E. Schwartz,
  8. Kyle Serniak,
  9. Max Hays,
  10. Jeffrey A. Grover,
  11. and William D. Oliver
Non-Hermitian Hamiltonians with complex eigenenergies are useful tools for describing the dynamics of open quantum systems. In particular, parity and time (PT) symmetric Hamiltonians
have generated interest due to the emergence of exceptional-point degeneracies, where both eigenenergies and eigenvectors coalesce as the energy spectrum transitions from real- to complex-valued. Because of the abrupt spectral response near exceptional points, such systems have been proposed as candidates for precision quantum sensing. In this work, we emulate a passive \PT~dimer using a two-mode, non-Hermitian system of superconducting qubits comprising one high-coherence qubit coupled to an intentionally lossy qubit via a tunable coupler. The loss is introduced by strongly coupling the qubit to a continuum of photonic modes in an open waveguide environment. Using both pulsed and continuous-wave measurements, we characterize the system dynamics near the exceptional point. We observe a behavior broadly consistent with an ideal passive \PT~dimer with some corrections due to the tunable coupler element. We extract the complex eigenenergies associated with the two modes and calculate the sensitivity as a function of the coupling strength. Confirming theoretical predictions, we observe no sensitivity enhancement near the quantum exceptional point. This study elucidates the limitations of exceptional-point systems as candidates for quantum-enhanced sensing.

Emergent Harmonics in Josephson Tunnel Junctions Due to Series Inductance

  1. Junghyun Kim,
  2. Max Hays,
  3. Ilan T. Rosen,
  4. Junyoung An,
  5. Helin Zhang,
  6. Aranya Goswami,
  7. Kate Azar,
  8. Jeffrey M. Gertler,
  9. Bethany M. Niedzielski,
  10. Mollie E. Schwartz,
  11. Terry P. Orlando,
  12. Jeffrey A. Grover,
  13. Kyle Serniak,
  14. and William D. Oliver
Josephson tunnel junctions are essential elements of superconducting quantum circuits. The operability of these circuits presumes a 2π-periodic sinusoidal potential of a tunnel junction,
but higher-order corrections to this Josephson potential, often referred to as „harmonics,“ cause deviations from the expected circuit behavior. Two potential sources for these harmonics are the intrinsic current-phase relationship of the Josephson junction and the inductance of the metallic traces connecting the junction to other circuit elements. Here, we introduce a method to distinguish the origin of the observed harmonics using nearly-symmetric superconducting quantum interference devices (SQUIDs). Spectroscopic measurements of level transitions in multiple devices reveal features that cannot be explained by a standard cosine potential, but are accurately reproduced when accounting for a second-harmonic contribution to the model. The observed scaling of the second harmonic with Josephson-junction size indicates that it is due almost entirely to the trace inductance. These results inform the design of next-generation superconducting circuits for quantum information processing and the investigation of the supercurrent diode effect.

Temperature and Magnetic-Field Dependence of Energy Relaxation in a Fluxonium Qubit

  1. Lamia Ateshian,
  2. Max Hays,
  3. David A. Rower,
  4. Helin Zhang,
  5. Kate Azar,
  6. Réouven Assouly,
  7. Leon Ding,
  8. Michael Gingras,
  9. Hannah Stickler,
  10. Bethany M. Niedzielski,
  11. Mollie E. Schwartz,
  12. Terry P. Orlando,
  13. Joel I.J. Wang,
  14. Simon Gustavsson,
  15. Jeffrey A. Grover,
  16. Kyle Serniak,
  17. and William D. Oliver
Noise from material defects at device interfaces is known to limit the coherence of superconducting circuits, yet our understanding of the defect origins and noise mechanisms remains
incomplete. Here we investigate the temperature and in-plane magnetic-field dependence of energy relaxation in a low-frequency fluxonium qubit, where the sensitivity to flux noise and charge noise arising from dielectric loss can be tuned by applied flux. We observe an approximately linear scaling of flux noise with temperature T and a power-law dependence of dielectric loss T3 up to 100 mK. Additionally, we find that the dielectric-loss-limited T1 decreases with weak in-plane magnetic fields, suggesting a potential magnetic-field response of the underlying charge-coupled defects. We implement a multi-level decoherence model in our analysis, motivated by the widely tunable matrix elements and transition energies approaching the thermal energy scale in our system. These findings offer insight for fluxonium coherence modeling and should inform microscopic theories of intrinsic noise in superconducting circuits.

Theory of Quasiparticle Generation by Microwave Drives in Superconducting Qubits

  1. Shoumik Chowdhury,
  2. Max Hays,
  3. Shantanu R. Jha,
  4. Kyle Serniak,
  5. Terry P. Orlando,
  6. Jeffrey A. Grover,
  7. and William D. Oliver
Microwave drives are commonly employed to control superconducting quantum circuits, enabling qubit gates, readout, and parametric interactions. As the drive frequencies are typically
an order of magnitude smaller than (twice) the superconducting gap, it is generally assumed that such drives do not disturb the BCS ground state. However, sufficiently strong drives can activate multi-photon pair-breaking processes that generate quasiparticles and result in qubit errors. In this work, we present a theoretical framework for calculating the rates of multi-photon-assisted pair-breaking transitions induced by both charge- and flux-coupled microwave drives. Through illustrative examples, we show that drive-induced QP generation may impact novel high-frequency dispersive readout architectures, as well as Floquet-engineered superconducting circuits operating under strong driving conditions.

Non-degenerate noise-resilient superconducting qubit

  1. Max Hays,
  2. Junghyun Kim,
  3. and William D. Oliver
We propose a superconducting qubit based on engineering the first and second harmonics of the Josephson energy and phase relation EJ1cosφ and EJ2cos2φ. By constructing a circuit such
that EJ2 is negative and |EJ1|≪|EJ2|, we create a periodic potential with two non-degenerate minima. The qubit, which we dub „harmonium“, is formed from the lowest-energy states of each minimum. Bit-flip protection of the qubit arises due to the localization of each qubit state to their respective minima, while phase-flip protection can be understood by considering the circuit within the Born-Oppenheimer approximation. We demonstrate with time-domain simulations that single- and two-qubit gates can be performed in approximately one hundred nanoseconds. Finally, we compute the qubit coherence times using numerical diagonalization of the complete circuit in conjunction with state-of-the-art noise models. We estimate out-of-manifold heating times on the order of milliseconds, which can be treated as erasure errors using conventional dispersive readout. We estimate pure-dephasing times on the order of many tens of milliseconds, and bit-flip times on the order of seconds.

Remote Entangling Gates for Spin Qubits in Quantum Dots using an Offset-Charge-Sensitive Transmon Coupler

  1. Harry Hanlim Kang,
  2. Ilan T. Rosen,
  3. Max Hays,
  4. Jeffrey A. Grover,
  5. and William D. Oliver
We propose a method to realize microwave-activated CZ gates between two remote spin qubits in quantum dots using an offset-charge-sensitive transmon coupler. The qubits are longitudinally
coupled to the coupler, so that the transition frequency of the coupler depends on the logical qubit states; a capacitive network model using first-quantized charge operators is developed to illustrate this. Driving the coupler transition then implements a conditional phase shift on the qubits. Two pulsing schemes are investigated: a rapid, off-resonant pulse with constant amplitude, and a pulse with envelope engineering that incorporates dynamical decoupling to mitigate charge noise. We develop non-Markovian time-domain simulations to accurately model gate performance in the presence of 1/fβ charge noise. Simulation results indicate that a CZ gate fidelity exceeding 90% is possible with realistic parameters and noise models.