A General Framework for Gradient-Based Optimization of Superconducting Quantum Circuits using Qubit Discovery as a Case Study

  1. Taha Rajabzadeh,
  2. Alex Boulton-McKeehan,
  3. Sam Bonkowsky,
  4. David I. Schuster,
  5. and Amir H. Safavi-Naeini
Engineering the Hamiltonian of a quantum system is fundamental to the design of quantum systems. Automating Hamiltonian design through gradient-based optimization can dramatically accelerate
this process. However, computing the gradients of eigenvalues and eigenvectors of a Hamiltonian–a large, sparse matrix–relative to system properties poses a significant challenge, especially for arbitrary systems. Superconducting quantum circuits offer substantial flexibility in Hamiltonian design, making them an ideal platform for this task. In this work, we present a comprehensive framework for the gradient-based optimization of superconducting quantum circuits, leveraging the SQcircuit software package. By addressing the challenge of calculating the gradient of the eigensystem for large, sparse Hamiltonians and integrating automatic differentiation within SQcircuit, our framework enables efficient and precise computation of gradients for various circuit properties or custom-defined metrics, streamlining the optimization process. We apply this framework to the qubit discovery problem, demonstrating its effectiveness in identifying qubit designs with superior performance metrics. The optimized circuits show improvements in a heuristic measure of gate count, upper bounds on gate speed, decoherence time, and resilience to noise and fabrication errors compared to existing qubits. While this methodology is showcased through qubit optimization and discovery, it is versatile and can be extended to tackle other optimization challenges in superconducting quantum hardware design.

Proposal for Superconducting Quantum Networks Using Multi-Octave Transduction to Lower Frequencies

  1. Takuma Makihara,
  2. Wentao Jiang,
  3. and Amir H. Safavi-Naeini
We propose networking superconducting quantum circuits by transducing their excitations (typically 4-8 GHz) to 100-500 MHz photons for transmission via cryogenic coaxial cables. Counter-intuitively,
this frequency downconversion reduces noise and transmission losses. We introduce a multi-octave asymmetrically threaded SQUID circuit (MOATS) capable of the required efficient, high-rate transduction. For a 100-meter cable with Qi=105 at 10 mK, our approach achieves single-photon fidelities of 0.962 at 200 MHz versus 0.772 at 8 GHz, and triples the lower bound on quantum channel capacity. This method enables kilometer-scale quantum links while maintaining high fidelities, combining improved performance with the practical advantages of flexible, compact coaxial cables.

A parametrically programmable delay line for microwave photons

  1. Takuma Makihara,
  2. Nathan Lee,
  3. Yudan Guo,
  4. Wenyan Guan,
  5. and Amir H. Safavi-Naeini
Delay lines capable of storing quantum information are crucial for advancing quantum repeaters and hardware efficient quantum computers. Traditionally, they are physically realized
as extended systems that support wave propagation, such as waveguides. But such delay lines typically provide limited control over the propagating fields. Here, we introduce a parametrically addressed delay line (PADL) for microwave photons that provides a high level of control over the dynamics of stored pulses, enabling us to arbitrarily delay or even swap pulses. By parametrically driving a three-waving mixing superconducting circuit element that is weakly hybridized with an ensemble of resonators, we engineer a spectral response that simulates that of a physical delay line, while providing fast control over the delay line’s properties and granting access to its internal modes. We illustrate the main features of the PADL, operating on pulses with energies on the order of a single photon, through a series of experiments, which include choosing which photon echo to emit, translating pulses in time, and swapping two pulses. We also measure the noise added to the delay line from our parametric interactions and find that the added noise is much less than one photon.

Analysis of arbitrary superconducting quantum circuits accompanied by a Python package: SQcircuit

  1. Taha Rajabzadeh,
  2. Zhaoyou Wang,
  3. Nathan Lee,
  4. Takuma Makihara,
  5. Yudan Guo,
  6. and Amir H. Safavi-Naeini
Superconducting quantum circuits are a promising hardware platform for realizing a fault-tolerant quantum computer. Accelerating progress in this field of research demands general approaches
and computational tools to analyze and design more complex superconducting circuits. We develop a framework to systematically construct a superconducting quantum circuit’s quantized Hamiltonian from its physical description. As is often the case with quantum descriptions of multicoordinate systems, the complexity rises rapidly with the number of variables. Therefore, we introduce a set of coordinate transformations with which we can find bases to diagonalize the Hamiltonian efficiently. Furthermore, we broaden our framework’s scope to calculate the circuit’s key properties required for optimizing and discovering novel qubits. We implement the methods described in this work in an open-source Python package SQcircuit. In this manuscript, we introduce the reader to the SQcircuit environment and functionality. We show through a series of examples how to analyze a number of interesting quantum circuits and obtain features such as the spectrum, coherence times, transition matrix elements, coupling operators, and the phase coordinate representation of eigenfunctions.

Automated discovery of autonomous quantum error correction schemes

  1. Zhaoyou Wang,
  2. Taha Rajabzadeh,
  3. Nathan Lee,
  4. and Amir H. Safavi-Naeini
We can encode a qubit in the energy levels of a quantum system. Relaxation and other dissipation processes lead to decay of the fidelity of this stored information. Is it possible to
preserve the quantum information for a longer time by introducing additional drives and dissipation? The existence of autonomous quantum error correcting codes answers this question in the positive. Nonetheless, discovering these codes for a real physical system, i.e., finding the encoding and the associated driving fields and bath couplings, remains a challenge that has required intuition and inspiration to overcome. In this work, we develop and demonstrate a computational approach based on adjoint optimization for discovering autonomous quantum error correcting codes given a description of a physical system. We implement an optimizer that searches for a logical subspace and control parameters to better preserve quantum information. We demonstrate our method on a system of a harmonic oscillator coupled to a lossy qubit, and find that varying the Hamiltonian distance in Fock space — a proxy for the control hardware complexity — leads to discovery of different and new error correcting schemes. We discover what we call the 3‾√ code, realizable with a Hamiltonian distance d=2, and propose a hardware-efficient implementation based on superconducting circuits.

Building a fault-tolerant quantum computer using concatenated cat codes

  1. Christopher Chamberland,
  2. Kyungjoo Noh,
  3. Patricio Arrangoiz-Arriola,
  4. Earl T. Campbell,
  5. Connor T. Hann,
  6. Joseph Iverson,
  7. Harald Putterman,
  8. Thomas C. Bohdanowicz,
  9. Steven T. Flammia,
  10. Andrew Keller,
  11. Gil Refael,
  12. John Preskill,
  13. Liang Jiang,
  14. Amir H. Safavi-Naeini,
  15. Oskar Painter,
  16. and Fernando G.S.L. Brandão
We present a comprehensive architectural analysis for a fault-tolerant quantum computer based on cat codes concatenated with outer quantum error-correcting codes. For the physical hardware,
we propose a system of acoustic resonators coupled to superconducting circuits with a two-dimensional layout. Using estimated near-term physical parameters for electro-acoustic systems, we perform a detailed error analysis of measurements and gates, including CNOT and Toffoli gates. Having built a realistic noise model, we numerically simulate quantum error correction when the outer code is either a repetition code or a thin rectangular surface code. Our next step toward universal fault-tolerant quantum computation is a protocol for fault-tolerant Toffoli magic state preparation that significantly improves upon the fidelity of physical Toffoli gates at very low qubit cost. To achieve even lower overheads, we devise a new magic-state distillation protocol for Toffoli states. Combining these results together, we obtain realistic full-resource estimates of the physical error rates and overheads needed to run useful fault-tolerant quantum algorithms. We find that with around 1,000 superconducting circuit components, one could construct a fault-tolerant quantum computer that can run circuits which are intractable for classical supercomputers. Hardware with 32,000 superconducting circuit components, in turn, could simulate the Hubbard model in a regime beyond the reach of classical computing.

Loss channels affecting lithium niobate phononic crystal resonators at cryogenic temperature

  1. E. Alex Wollack,
  2. Agnetta Y. Cleland,
  3. Patricio Arrangoiz-Arriola,
  4. Timothy P. McKenna,
  5. Rachel G. Gruenke,
  6. Rishi N. Patel,
  7. Wentao Jiang,
  8. Christopher J. Sarabalis,
  9. and Amir H. Safavi-Naeini
We investigate the performance of microwave-frequency phononic crystal resonators fabricated on thin-film lithium niobate for integration with superconducting quantum circuits. For
different design geometries at millikelvin temperatures, we achieve mechanical internal quality factors Qi above 105−106 at high microwave drive power, corresponding to 5×106 phonons inside the resonator. By sweeping the defect size of resonators with identical mirror cell designs, we are able to indirectly observe signatures of the complete phononic bandgap via the resonators‘ internal quality factors. Examination of quality factors‘ temperature dependence shows how superconducting and two-level system (TLS) loss channels impact device performance. Finally, we observe an anomalous low-temperature frequency shift consistent with resonant TLS decay and find that material choice can help to mitigate these losses.

Cryogenic microwave-to-optical conversion using a triply-resonant lithium niobate on sapphire transducer

  1. Timothy P. McKenna,
  2. Jeremy D. Witmer,
  3. Rishi N. Patel,
  4. Wentao Jiang,
  5. Raphaël Van Laer,
  6. Patricio Arrangoiz-Arriola,
  7. E. Alex Wollack,
  8. Jason F. Herrmann,
  9. and Amir H. Safavi-Naeini
Quantum networks are likely to have a profound impact on the way we compute and communicate in the future. In order to wire together superconducting quantum processors over kilometer-scale
distances, we need transducers that can generate entanglement between the microwave and optical domains with high fidelity. We present an integrated electro-optic transducer that combines low-loss lithium niobate photonics with superconducting microwave resonators on a sapphire substrate. Our triply-resonant device operates in a dilution refrigerator and converts microwave photons to optical photons with an on-chip efficiency of 6.6×10−6 and a conversion bandwidth of 20 MHz. We discuss design trade-offs in this device, including strategies to manage acoustic loss, and outline ways to increase the conversion efficiency in the future.

Electric fields for light: Propagation of microwave photons along a synthetic dimension

  1. Nathan R. A. Lee,
  2. Marek Pechal,
  3. E. Alex Wollack,
  4. Patricio Arrangoiz-Arriola,
  5. Zhaoyou Wang,
  6. and Amir H. Safavi-Naeini
The evenly-spaced modes of an electromagnetic resonator are coupled to each other by appropriate time-modulation, leading to dynamics analogous to those of particles hopping between
different sites of a lattice. This substitution of a real spatial dimension of a lattice with a „synthetic'“ dimension in frequency space greatly reduces the hardware complexity of an analog quantum simulator. Complex control and read-out of a highly multi-moded structure can thus be accomplished with very few physical control lines. We demonstrate this concept with microwave photons in a superconducting transmission line resonator by modulating the system parameters at frequencies near the resonator’s free spectral range and observing propagation of photon wavepackets in time domain. The linear propagation dynamics are equivalent to a tight-binding model, which we probe by measuring scattering parameters between frequency sites. We extract an approximate tight-binding dispersion relation for the synthetic lattice and initialize photon wavepackets with well-defined quasimomenta and group velocities. As an example application of this platform in simulating a physical system, we demonstrate Bloch oscillations associated with a particle in a periodic potential and subject to a constant external field. The simulated field strongly affects the photon dynamics despite photons having zero charge. Our observation of photon dynamics along a synthetic frequency dimension generalizes immediately to topological photonics and single-photon power levels, and expands the range of physical systems addressable by quantum simulation.

Superconducting circuit quantum computing with nanomechanical resonators as storage

  1. Marek Pechal,
  2. Patricio Arrangoiz-Arriola,
  3. and Amir H. Safavi-Naeini
We analyze the quantum information processing capability of a superconducting transmon circuit used to mediate interactions between quantum information stored in a collection of phononic
crystal cavity resonators. Having only a single processing element to be controlled externally makes this approach significantly less hardware-intensive than traditional architectures with individual control of each qubit. Moreover, when compared with the commonly considered alternative approach using coplanar waveguide or 3d cavity microwave resonators for storage, the nanomechanical resonators offer both very long lifetime and small size — two conflicting requirements for microwave resonators. A detailed gate error analysis leads to an optimal value for the qubit-resonator coupling rate as a function of the number of mechanical resonators in the system. For a given set of system parameters, a specific amount of coupling and number of resonators is found to optimize the quantum volume, an approximate measure for the computational capacity of a system. We see this volume is higher in the proposed hybrid nanomechanical architecture than in the competing on-chip electromagnetic approach.