Demonstrating a superconducting dual-rail cavity qubit with erasure-detected logical measurements

  1. Kevin S. Chou,
  2. Tali Shemma,
  3. Heather McCarrick,
  4. Tzu-Chiao Chien,
  5. James D. Teoh,
  6. Patrick Winkel,
  7. Amos Anderson,
  8. Jonathan Chen,
  9. Jacob Curtis,
  10. Stijn J. de Graaf,
  11. John W.O. Garmon,
  12. Benjamin Gudlewski,
  13. William D. Kalfus,
  14. Trevor Keen,
  15. Nishaad Khedkar,
  16. Chan U Lei,
  17. Gangqiang Liu,
  18. Pinlei Lu,
  19. Yao Lu,
  20. Aniket Maiti,
  21. Luke Mastalli-Kelly,
  22. Nitish Mehta,
  23. Shantanu O. Mundhada,
  24. Anirudh Narla,
  25. Taewan Noh,
  26. Takahiro Tsunoda,
  27. Sophia H. Xue,
  28. Joseph O. Yuan,
  29. Luigi Frunzio,
  30. Jose Aumentado,
  31. Shruti Puri,
  32. Steven M. Girvin,
  33. S. Harvey Moseley Jr.,
  34. and Robert J. Schoelkopf
A critical challenge in developing scalable error-corrected quantum systems is the accumulation of errors while performing operations and measurements. One promising approach is to
design a system where errors can be detected and converted into erasures. A recent proposal aims to do this using a dual-rail encoding with superconducting cavities. In this work, we implement such a dual-rail cavity qubit and use it to demonstrate a projective logical measurement with erasure detection. We measure logical state preparation and measurement errors at the 0.01%-level and detect over 99% of cavity decay events as erasures. We use the precision of this new measurement protocol to distinguish different types of errors in this system, finding that while decay errors occur with probability ∼0.2% per microsecond, phase errors occur 6 times less frequently and bit flips occur at least 170 times less frequently. These findings represent the first confirmation of the expected error hierarchy necessary to concatenate dual-rail erasure qubits into a highly efficient erasure code.

Observation of Josephson Harmonics in Tunnel Junctions

  1. Dennis Willsch,
  2. Dennis Rieger,
  3. Patrick Winkel,
  4. Madita Willsch,
  5. Christian Dickel,
  6. Jonas Krause,
  7. Yoichi Ando,
  8. Raphaël Lescanne,
  9. Zaki Leghtas,
  10. Nicholas T. Bronn,
  11. Pratiti Deb,
  12. Olivia Lanes,
  13. Zlatko K. Minev,
  14. Benedikt Dennig,
  15. Simon Geisert,
  16. Simon Günzler,
  17. Sören Ihssen,
  18. Patrick Paluch,
  19. Thomas Reisinger,
  20. Roudy Hanna,
  21. Jin Hee Bae,
  22. Peter Schüffelgen,
  23. Detlev Grützmacher,
  24. Luiza Buimaga-Iarinca,
  25. Cristian Morari,
  26. Wolfgang Wernsdorfer,
  27. David P. DiVincenzo,
  28. Kristel Michielsen,
  29. Gianluigi Catelani,
  30. and Ioan M. Pop
An accurate understanding of the Josephson effect is the keystone of quantum information processing with superconducting hardware. Here we show that the celebrated sinφ current-phase
relation (CφR) of Josephson junctions (JJs) fails to fully describe the energy spectra of transmon artificial atoms across various samples and laboratories. While the microscopic theory of JJs contains higher harmonics in the CφR, these have generally been assumed to give insignificant corrections for tunnel JJs, due to the low transparency of the conduction channels. However, this assumption might not be justified given the disordered nature of the commonly used AlOx tunnel barriers. Indeed, a mesoscopic model of tunneling through an inhomogeneous AlOx barrier predicts contributions from higher Josephson harmonics of several %. By including these in the transmon Hamiltonian, we obtain orders of magnitude better agreement between the computed and measured energy spectra. The measurement of Josephson harmonics in the CφR of standard tunnel junctions prompts a reevaluation of current models for superconducting hardware and it offers a highly sensitive probe towards optimizing tunnel barrier uniformity.

Dual-rail encoding with superconducting cavities

  1. James D. Teoh,
  2. Patrick Winkel,
  3. Harshvardhan K. Babla,
  4. Benjamin J. Chapman,
  5. Jahan Claes,
  6. Stijn J. de Graaf,
  7. John W.O. Garmon,
  8. William D. Kalfus,
  9. Yao Lu,
  10. Aniket Maiti,
  11. Kaavya Sahay,
  12. Neel Thakur,
  13. Takahiro Tsunoda,
  14. Sophia H. Xue,
  15. Luigi Frunzio,
  16. Steven M. Girvin,
  17. Shruti Puri,
  18. and Robert J. Schoelkopf
The design of quantum hardware that reduces and mitigates errors is essential for practical quantum error correction (QEC) and useful quantum computations. To this end, we introduce
the circuit-QED dual-rail qubit in which our physical qubit is encoded in the single-photon subspace of two superconducting cavities. The dominant photon loss errors can be detected and converted into erasure errors, which are much easier to correct. In contrast to linear optics, a circuit-QED implementation of the dual-rail code offers completely new capabilities. Using a single transmon ancilla, we describe a universal gate set that includes state preparation, logical readout, and parametrizable single and two-qubit gates. Moreover, first-order hardware errors due to the cavity and transmon in all of these operations can be detected and converted to erasure errors, leaving background Pauli errors that are orders of magnitude smaller. Hence, the dual-rail cavity qubit delivers an optimal hierarchy of errors and rates, and is expected to be well below the relevant QEC thresholds with today’s devices.

A quantum Szilard engine for two-level systems coupled to a qubit

  1. Martin Spiecker,
  2. Patrick Paluch,
  3. Niv Drucker,
  4. Shlomi Matityahu,
  5. Daria Gusenkova,
  6. Nicolas Gosling,
  7. Simon Günzler,
  8. Dennis Rieger,
  9. Ivan Takmakov,
  10. Francesco Valenti,
  11. Patrick Winkel,
  12. Richard Gebauer,
  13. Oliver Sander,
  14. Gianluigi Catelani,
  15. Alexander Shnirman,
  16. Alexey V. Ustinov,
  17. Wolfgang Wernsdorfer,
  18. Yonatan Cohen,
  19. and Ioan M. Pop
The innate complexity of solid state physics exposes superconducting quantum circuits to interactions with uncontrolled degrees of freedom degrading their coherence. By using a simple
stabilization sequence we show that a superconducting fluxonium qubit is coupled to a two-level system (TLS) environment of unknown origin, with a relatively long energy relaxation time exceeding 50ms. Implementing a quantum Szilard engine with an active feedback control loop allows us to decide whether the qubit heats or cools its TLS environment. The TLSs can be cooled down resulting in a four times lower qubit population, or they can be heated to manifest themselves as a negative temperature environment corresponding to a qubit population of ∼80%. We show that the TLSs and the qubit are each other’s dominant loss mechanism and that the qubit relaxation is independent of the TLS populations. Understanding and mitigating TLS environments is therefore not only crucial to improve qubit lifetimes but also to avoid non-Markovian qubit dynamics.

Operating in a deep underground facility improves the locking of gradiometric fluxonium qubits at the sweet spots

  1. Daria Gusenkova,
  2. Francesco Valenti,
  3. Martin Spiecker,
  4. Simon Günzler,
  5. Patrick Paluch,
  6. Dennis Rieger,
  7. Larisa-Milena Pioraş-Ţimbolmaş,
  8. Liviu P. Zârbo,
  9. Nicola Casali,
  10. Ivan Colantoni,
  11. Angelo Cruciani,
  12. Stefano Pirro,
  13. Laura Cardani,
  14. Alexandru Petrescu,
  15. Wolfgang Wernsdorfer,
  16. Patrick Winkel,
  17. and Ioan M. Pop
We demonstrate flux-bias locking and operation of a gradiometric fluxonium artificial atom using two symmetric granular aluminum (grAl) loops to implement the superinductor. The gradiometric
fluxonium shows two orders of magnitude suppression of sensitivity to homogeneous magnetic fields, which can be an asset for hybrid quantum systems requiring strong magnetic field biasing. By cooling down the device in an external magnetic field while crossing the metal-to-superconductor transition, the gradiometric fluxonium can be locked either at 0 or Φ0/2 effective flux bias, corresponding to an even or odd number of trapped fluxons, respectively. At mK temperatures, the fluxon parity prepared during initialization survives to magnetic field bias exceeding 100Φ0. However, even for states biased in the vicinity of 1Φ0, we observe unexpectedly short fluxon lifetimes of a few hours, which cannot be explained by thermal or quantum phase slips. When operating in a deep-underground cryostat of the Gran Sasso laboratory, the fluxon lifetimes increase to days, indicating that ionizing events activate phase slips in the grAl superinductor.

Quantum non-demolition dispersive readout of a superconducting artificial atom using large photon numbers

  1. Daria Gusenkova,
  2. Martin Spiecker,
  3. Richard Gebauer,
  4. Madita Willsch,
  5. Francesco Valenti,
  6. Nick Karcher,
  7. Lukas Grünhaupt,
  8. Ivan Takmakov,
  9. Patrick Winkel,
  10. Dennis Rieger,
  11. Alexey V. Ustinov,
  12. Nicolas Roch,
  13. Wolfgang Wernsdorfer,
  14. Kristel Michielsen,
  15. Oliver Sander,
  16. and Ioan M. Pop
Reading out the state of superconducting artificial atoms typically relies on dispersive coupling to a readout resonator. For a given system noise temperature, increasing the circulating
photon number n¯ in the resonator enables a shorter measurement time and is therefore expected to reduce readout errors caused by spontaneous atom transitions. However, increasing n¯ is generally observed to also increase these transition rates. Here we present a fluxonium artificial atom in which we measure an overall flat dependence of the transition rates between its first two states as a function of n¯, up to n¯≈200. Despite the fact that we observe the expected decrease of the dispersive shift with increasing readout power, the signal-to-noise ratio continuously improves with increasing n¯. Even without the use of a parametric amplifier, at n¯=74, we measure fidelities of 99% and 93% for feedback-assisted ground and excited state preparation, respectively.

State preparation of a fluxonium qubit with feedback from a custom FPGA-based platform

  1. Richard Gebauer,
  2. Nick Karcher,
  3. Daria Gusenkova,
  4. Martin Spiecker,
  5. Lukas Grünhaupt,
  6. Ivan Takmakov,
  7. Patrick Winkel,
  8. Luca Planat,
  9. Nicolas Roch,
  10. Wolfgang Wernsdorfer,
  11. Alexey V. Ustinov,
  12. Marc Weber,
  13. Martin Weides,
  14. Ioan M. Pop,
  15. and Oliver Sander
We developed a versatile integrated control and readout instrument for experiments with superconducting quantum bits (qubits), based on a field-programmable gate array (FPGA) platform.
Using this platform, we perform measurement-based, closed-loop feedback operations with 428ns platform latency. The feedback capability is instrumental in realizing active reset initialization of the qubit into the ground state in a time much shorter than its energy relaxation time T1. We show experimental results demonstrating reset of a fluxonium qubit with 99.4% fidelity, using a readout-and-drive pulse sequence approximately 1.5μs long. Compared to passive ground state initialization through thermalization, with the time constant given by T1= 80μs, the use of the FPGA-based platform allows us to improve both the fidelity and the time of the qubit initialization by an order of magnitude.

Implementation of a transmon qubit using superconducting granular aluminum

  1. Patrick Winkel,
  2. Kiril Borisov,
  3. Lukas Grünhaupt,
  4. Dennis Rieger,
  5. Martin Spiecker,
  6. Francesco Valenti,
  7. Alexey V. Ustinov,
  8. Wolfgang Wernsdorfer,
  9. and Ioan M. Pop
The high kinetic inductance offered by granular aluminum (grAl) has recently been employed for linear inductors in superconducting high-impedance qubits and kinetic inductance detectors.
Due to its large critical current density compared to typical Josephson junctions, its resilience to external magnetic fields, and its low dissipation, grAl may also provide a robust source of non-linearity for strongly driven quantum circuits, topological superconductivity, and hybrid systems. Having said that, can the grAl non-linearity be sufficient to build a qubit? Here we show that a small grAl volume (10×200×500nm3) shunted by a thin film aluminum capacitor results in a microwave oscillator with anharmonicity α two orders of magnitude larger than its spectral linewidth Γ01, effectively forming a transmon qubit. With increasing drive power, we observe several multi-photon transitions starting from the ground state, from which we extract α=2π×4.48MHz. Resonance fluorescence measurements of the |0>→|1> transition yield an intrinsic qubit linewidth γ=2π×10kHz, corresponding to a lifetime of 16μs. This linewidth remains below 2π×150kHz for in-plane magnetic fields up to ∼70mT.

Non-degenerate parametric amplifiers based on dispersion engineered Josephson junction arrays

  1. Patrick Winkel,
  2. Ivan Takmakov,
  3. Dennis Rieger,
  4. Luca Planat,
  5. Wiebke Hasch-Guichard,
  6. Lukas Grünhaupt,
  7. Nataliya Maleeva,
  8. Farshad Foroughi,
  9. Fabio Henriques,
  10. Kiril Borisov,
  11. Julian Ferrero,
  12. Alexey V. Ustinov,
  13. Wolfgang Wernsdorfer,
  14. Nicolas Roch,
  15. and Ioan M. Pop
Determining the state of a qubit on a timescale much shorter than its relaxation time is an essential requirement for quantum information processing. With the aid of a new type of non-degenerate
parametric amplifier, we demonstrate the continuous detection of quantum jumps of a transmon qubit with 90% fidelity in state discrimination. Entirely fabricated with standard two-step optical lithography techniques, this type of parametric amplifier consists of a dispersion engineered Josephson junction (JJ) array. By using long arrays, containing 103 JJs, we can obtain amplification at multiple eigenmodes with frequencies below 10 GHz, which is the typical range for qubit readout. Moreover, by introducing a moderate flux tunability of each mode, employing superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID) junctions, a single amplifier device could potentially cover the entire frequency band between 1 and 10 GHz.

Onset of phase diffusion in high kinetic inductance granular aluminum micro-SQUIDs

  1. Felix Friedrich,
  2. Patrick Winkel,
  3. Kiril Borisov,
  4. Hannes Seeger,
  5. Christoph Sürgers,
  6. Ioan M. Pop,
  7. and Wolfgang Wernsdorfer
Superconducting granular aluminum is attracting increasing interest due to its high kinetic inductance and low dissipation, favoring its use in kinetic inductance particle detectors,
superconducting resonators or quantum bits. We perform switching current measurements on DC-SQUIDs, obtained by introducing two identical geometric constrictions in granular aluminum rings of various normal-state resistivities in the range from ρn=250μΩcm to 5550μΩcm. The relative high kinetic inductance of the SQUID loop, in the range of tens of nH, leads to a suppression of the modulation in the measured switching current versus magnetic flux, accompanied by a distortion towards a triangular shape. We observe a change in the temperature dependence of the switching current histograms with increasing normal-state film resistivity. This behavior suggests the onset of a diffusive motion of the superconducting phase across the constrictions in the two-dimensional washboard potential of the SQUIDs, which could be caused by a change of the local electromagnetic environment of films with increasing normal-state resistivities.